Plastering advice for Lowestoft homes

Skim or replaster: which does your wall need?

Two plasterers look at the same room. One prices a skim. The other says it all has to come off. The second price is double the first, and you have no idea who is right.

You can get most of the way to the answer yourself, with your knuckles and five minutes.

The difference in one paragraph

A skim is a new surface. Two thin coats of finishing plaster, a few millimetres in all, go over what is already there. A replaster is a new wall covering. The old plaster comes off, and a thick base coat and a finish go back on. A skim relies on the old plaster to hold it up. A replaster relies on nothing but the brick.

The knuckle test

Begin at one corner and knock your way across the wall, low, middle and high.

  • A dull, solid sound means the plaster is stuck fast.
  • A hollow, rattly sound means it has come away from the wall.
  • Mark the edge of each hollow patch in pencil as you go.

Now stand back and look at the pencil marks. One or two patches the size of a dinner plate can be cut out and filled before a skim. If a third of the wall or more is hollow, patching it first costs about as much as taking it all off.

Signs a skim will do

  • The plaster sounds solid nearly everywhere
  • Cracks are fine and do not move
  • The surface is rough, pitted or scarred but hard
  • The wall is dry, with no tide marks or salty bloom
  • You are covering old paint, filler or the marks left by wallpaper

Signs it has to come off

  • Large hollow areas
  • Plaster that is soft, sandy or crumbles under a thumbnail
  • Damp patches, staining or white salts
  • Cracks that have opened again after filling
  • Plaster that has been soaked by a leak or a flood

Damp is the one that catches people out. New plaster of any kind will fail on a wall that is still wet or full of salt. Along the Lowestoft seafront, and in homes that have flooded, that question comes before all the others. See damp, salt and plaster.

What the guides say each one costs

Per square metre, a UK plastering guide gives £15 to £25 for a skim and £30 to £40 for a full two-coat replaster. By the room, its two guides show the gap like this.

JobUK guide price
Skimming the walls of a medium room£425 to £600
Plastering a double bedroom£600 to £850

Typical UK guide prices from published UK two guides, not quotes. The guides measure rooms in different ways, so use the table for a rough comparison only.

A third option: board and skim

There is a third option that plasterers often suggest. The old plaster comes off, or stays if it is firm enough to fix through, and plasterboard goes on to the wall. The board is then skimmed.

It is quicker than a wet replaster and gives a very flat wall. It does take a little off the size of the room, and it is not the answer for a damp wall or for an old house that needs lime. Our page on plasterboarding in Lowestoft has more.

When two plasterers disagree

Ask each one to show you why. A plasterer who wants it all off should be able to knock on the wall and let you hear the hollow parts. One who says a skim will do ought to explain what happens to the patches you marked. The right answer is usually the one that comes with a reason.

Then ask what happens if the skim option turns out worse than it looked once the wallpaper is off. A fair plasterer will give you the price for both before a bucket is mixed.

The services themselves are set out on our pages for wall skimming and replastering.

Common questions

Is skimming cheaper than plastering?

Yes. A UK plastering guide puts a skim at £15 to £25 a square metre and a full replaster at £30 to £40. A skim uses less plaster, takes less time and makes far less mess, because nothing is knocked off the wall. It is only the cheaper job if the wall beneath is sound. A skim over failing plaster is money lost.

Can half a wall be replastered and the rest skimmed?

Yes, and it is common. The bad area is taken back and filled level with a base coat, then the whole wall is skimmed in one go so there is no visible join.

Not sure after the knuckle test?

That is normal. Plaster can sound solid and still be on borrowed time, and only someone who does this daily can judge the edge cases. Guess wrong in the cheap direction and you pay for the wall twice.

Say what you heard when you knocked, and where in Lowestoft you live. A second look from a plasterer costs nothing here.

Get a free plastering quote

Takes a minute. No email asked for.

By sending this form you agree to your details being shared with a local plasterer so they can contact you. See our privacy notice.

Get a free quote